Understanding Contempt of Court: Avoiding Misguided Legal Advice

Contempt-of-court charges are serious allegations that can have significant legal repercussions. However, many unscrupulous attorneys often mislead their clients into pursuing these charges without fully understanding the necessary legal criteria. While it’s true that there are commonly known tests for contempt of court, a critical third test is often overlooked, leading to misguided legal strategies and ultimately, failed cases.

The Three Legal Tests for Contempt of Court

Understanding contempt of court requires clarity on the three essential tests determining whether a contempt charge is valid. Many attorneys focus only on the first two, which are widely known:

  1. Existence of a Court Order: A clear, unambiguous court order must be in place.
  2. Violation of the Court Order: The order must be demonstrably broken or violated.

While passing these two tests is crucial, they alone do not suffice for a successful contempt of court charge. This is where unscrupulous attorneys often mislead their clients, suggesting that these two criteria are enough to secure a victory. However, there’s a third, frequently overlooked, test that is critical to the integrity of contempt of court charge:

  1. Contemptuous Intent: The violation of the court order must be due to a blatant, overt contempt for the court. This means that the individual must have broken the order as a deliberate act of defiance against the court’s authority, viewing themselves above the judicial system.

The Misconception of Simplified Contempt Charges

Unscrupulous or uninformed attorneys may simplify the contempt of court process to their clients, focusing only on the existence and violation of a court order. They often neglect to explain the necessity of proving contemptuous intent, leading to failed cases and frustrated clients.

Contempt of court is not merely about whether an order was broken. It’s about the mindset and the deliberate defiance of the court’s authority. This third test ensures that contempt charges are not abused and reserved for those genuinely undermining the judicial system.

Proving Contemptuous Intent

To successfully argue a contempt of court charge, it is essential to demonstrate that the order was broken with a contemptuous attitude towards the court. This involves proving that the defendant’s actions were not merely accidental or due to external circumstances but were a deliberate act of defiance. Examples of such contemptuous behaviour include:

  • Direct Insults to the Court: Verbal or written statements disrespecting the court’s authority.
  • Deliberate Non-compliance: Ignoring court orders in a manner that shows a clear disregard for the legal process.
  • Evasion Tactics: Using deceptive methods to avoid complying with court orders, indicating an intent to undermine the court’s authority.

Misguided Legal Advice and Its Consequences

Many clients fall victim to attorneys who promise easy victories by oversimplifying the contempt of court criteria. These clients are often unaware of the necessity of proving contemptuous intent and end up pursuing charges that are bound to fail. This not only wastes valuable time and resources but also diminishes their credibility in the eyes of the court.

How to Properly Approach Contempt of Court Charges

To avoid falling into the trap of misguided legal advice, it’s essential to seek attorneys who understand and respect the full scope of contempt of court criteria. Our litigation teams, at Fathers 4 Justice, meticulously evaluate each case to ensure all three tests are satisfied before proceeding with a contempt of court charge.

Steps to Take

  1. Consult with Fathers 4 Justice South Africa Litigation Department: Our legal department will ensure a comprehensive understanding of contempt of court charges.
  2. Evaluate the Evidence: Collect clear evidence that not only was the court order broken but that it was done with contemptuous intent.
  3. Build a Strong Case: Focus on demonstrating the defendant’s contemptuous mindset through documented behaviour and statements.
  4. Consider Alternative Explanations: Be prepared to address and refute any reasonable explanations for the violation that do not involve contempt.

Contact Us

If you are unsure whether your case qualifies for a contempt of court charge, get in touch with us. Our experienced litigation department will assess the facts and provide you with the best legal advice. We specialize in handling complex cases and ensuring that all necessary criteria are met for a successful contempt of court charge.


Understanding the full scope of contempt of court charges is crucial for any legal strategy. By recognizing the importance of contemptuous intent, clients can avoid misguided legal advice and build stronger, more successful cases. Always ensure your legal team is well-versed in all three tests for contempt of court to avoid unnecessary failures and legal frustrations. If you need expert advice on your case, contact Fathers 4 Justice for a thorough evaluation and professional guidance.

By following these guidelines, you can navigate the complexities of contempt of court charges with confidence and clarity, ensuring that your legal actions are grounded in a comprehensive understanding of the law.

Verified by MonsterInsights